Scenic mountain view near Show Low, Arizona
Show Low Property Specialists

Ready to Find Your Next
Show Low Home?

From long-term rentals to vacation retreats, we manage every detail so you can enjoy the high-country lifestyle without the hassle.

Explore Properties Get in Touch
15+
Years Serving
200+
Properties Managed
100%
Client Satisfaction
Scroll
What We Do

Comprehensive Rental Services

Whether you own property or are searching for your next rental, we provide the expertise and personal attention you deserve.

Property Management

Full-service management from tenant screening to maintenance coordination — we handle the details so your investment works for you.

Rental Search

Finding the right home in Show Low shouldn't be complicated. We match you with properties that fit your lifestyle and budget.

Vacation Rentals

Short-term and seasonal rentals near White Mountain Lake and the Sierra Anexas — perfect for outdoor enthusiasts and weekend getaways.

Maintenance & Repairs

Round-the-clock maintenance support with vetted local contractors. Your property stays in top condition year-round.

Lease Administration

Professional lease preparation, rent collection, and compliance management — everything handled with precision and care.

Local Market Expertise

Deep knowledge of the Show Low and White Mountain area means better pricing, faster placements, and smarter decisions for every property.

Downtown Show Low, Arizona street view
About Us

Your Neighbors in Property Care

Shumway Valley Rentals has been a cornerstone of the Show Low rental community for over 15 years. We're not a national chain — we're your neighbors, and we care about this community the way you do.

Whether you're a property owner looking for reliable management or a renter searching for the perfect home in the White Mountains, we bring local expertise, honest communication, and a genuine investment in your satisfaction. Every property we touch receives the same attention we'd give our own homes.

Locally Owned & Operated
Responsive Communication
Transparent Reporting
Community Focused
Learn More About Us
Our Portfolio

Featured Properties

Browse a selection of managed rentals across Show Low and the surrounding White Mountain area.

Cozy cabin rental near Show Low
For Rent

Mountain View Cabin

Show Low, AZ
3 Beds · 2 Baths · 1,450 sq ft
Inquire About This Property
Family home rental in Show Low
For Rent

Downtown Show Low Home

Show Low, AZ
4 Beds · 2.5 Baths · 2,100 sq ft
Inquire About This Property
Vacation rental near White Mountain Lake
Vacation Rental

Lakefront Retreat

White Mountain Lake, AZ
2 Beds · 1 Bath · 980 sq ft
Inquire About This Property
View All Available Rentals
Why Choose Us

The Shumway Valley Difference

1

Personal Attention, Every Time

You'll never be passed to a call center. We know our property owners and tenants by name, and we respond personally — not through automated systems.

2

Deep Local Knowledge

We live here, we work here, and we understand the neighborhoods, schools, and market trends that make Show Low and White Mountain a special place to live.

3

Proactive Property Care

We don't wait for problems to escalate. Regular inspections, preventive maintenance, and quick response to issues protect your investment and your peace of mind.

4

Honest, Transparent Communication

Clear reports, straightforward pricing, and no hidden fees. We believe you deserve to understand exactly what's happening with your property at all times.

Let's Talk About
Your Property Goals

Whether you're ready to list a property, need a reliable management partner, or are searching for your next rental home — we'd love to hear from you.

Schedule a Consultation Call (928) 235-2211
Testimonials

What Our Clients Say

"Shumway Valley Rentals has been managing our property for years. Their responsiveness and honesty set them apart from everything else we've experienced."

M.R.
Property Owner
Show Low, AZ

"We found the perfect vacation rental through them for our family get-togethers. The process was smooth and the team went above and beyond."

S.T.
Vacation Rental Guest
White Mountain Lake, AZ

"As a first-time renter, I was nervous about the process. The team at Shumway Valley made it simple and stress-free — I found exactly what I needed."

J.L.
Tenant
Show Low, AZ
Get in Touch

Contact Us

Have questions about a property, need property management info, or want to schedule a viewing? Reach out — we're here to help.

Visit Us

2833 Old School House Rd
Show Low, AZ 85901-9422

Call Us

(928) 235-2211

Mon–Fri: 9am – 5pm

Send Us a Message

Is this your business?This is my business